Elisabeth Shue as Julie Finlay
Where do we even get started with Elisabeth Shue? She has starred in some of the greatest films ever created – such as The Karate Kid, Adventures in Babysitting, Cocktail, Back to the Future (parts II and III), and recently Death Wish. Yeah, we told you the list was impressive. Shue portrayed Julie Finlay from 2012 to 2015, fans were devastated to see her character killed off.
Robyn Lively as Sarah Myers
The now 46 year old first began acting when she was just a kid. Robyn Lively starred in Silver Spoons, Punky Brewster, Wildcats, The Karate Kid Part III, and Not Quite Human. Since then she’s starred and appeared in multiple films and television series. She appeared in the 2005 episode “Manhattan Manhunt” of CSI: NY.